Yuku free message boards

Greeting Waterrock

Thank you for sharing you oppinion about propet Muhammad. I dont know where the source about your story, if you have read Muhammad history before he became a prophet, maybe you can understand that Muhammad is a honest man that make every people in his town call him 'al-Amiin' (the honest), and work as an ordinary merchant in his khafilah (group of nomad merchant).

As you can read about civilization on his time, you'll know that reading and writing is kind of an embarassing thing - people in that time more admire people who can tells story, tells poem, singing about other old story about king and stuff. Only a very few people can read that time.

Other way to find if is true Quran is a book copied from others, by comparing what Quran tells about something with other old scripture telling the same thing. For example about human birth, what old Greek science tells about this. and what Quran tells about this.

Little thing that contain in Quran:
- Al-Alaq (Quran 96:1-5), the first 5 revelation for Muhammad. al Alaq literally means 'something which cling'. Old schollar/translator get confused by this and write it as 'clot' (thick coagulated blood). I dont know if there is any old scientis that use mini-microscope, put it in mother's womb, find this clinging thing, and write a book about this. and then Muhammad copied and create Quran.

- Iron, please see Quran 57:25. Old translator use '..We created iron..' the literall meaning of it is '..we sent down iron..'. Old translator also confused for what is the meaning of 'sent down iron', is it from the sky that droped to earth? Yes, its true that iron is not from earth, it was sent down from meteorits million years ago. Correct me if im wrong.

- The returning sky, (Q 86:11), old translator translate it as '..sky which gives rain..'. literally its mean 'sky which returns (send back down)'. If Muhammad copied this from other scholar, I believe radio wave have been invented at that time.

- Quran 4:56, about God change/create new skins to make them (disbelieved) can taste the punishment. Its interesting, why this verse point '..new skins, to make them taste punishment'. Are they only feel hurt as long their skins still there? How bout the other part, are they can't sense pain?

I'm limitted, also poor in English, if there are something wrong then its my fault. The truth is only belong to Allah.

Thank you for reading.