Q: In Matthew 14:1-2, Herod thought that Jesus was John the Baptist risen from the dead. Apparently this was a common opinion (see Mt. 16:13-15 and its parallels). If many of Jesus contemporaries could be so easily fooled regarding John the Baptist, what does this do to the credibility of Jesus resurrection?
A: It highlights the differences between those who were spreading each idea. Herod got the idea at a distance. And Johns disciples (besides those who had joined Jesus) dont seem to be in the group saying that Jesus was Resurrected-John. But the people who initiated and spread the news that Jesus was raised from the dead -- and that they had seen Him and had eaten with Him -- were His closest followers. Something like this is frequently the difference between a hopeful (or fearful) rumor and genuine news.
Yours in Christ,
Waterrock
A: It highlights the differences between those who were spreading each idea. Herod got the idea at a distance. And Johns disciples (besides those who had joined Jesus) dont seem to be in the group saying that Jesus was Resurrected-John. But the people who initiated and spread the news that Jesus was raised from the dead -- and that they had seen Him and had eaten with Him -- were His closest followers. Something like this is frequently the difference between a hopeful (or fearful) rumor and genuine news.
Yours in Christ,
Waterrock
