ironsheikh wrote:

If I punched you right now, I'd love to see you not follow this commandment.

Okay.
You punch me, i will more than likely not punch you back.
I'll just have you prosecuted for assault.

My problem with this instruction is that there's no higher moral road. We're allowed and expected to go as low as our attacker.
Someone punches me, i punch him.
Someone rapes my wife, i rape his wife.
Someone kicks my child, i kick their child.
Someone blows up my church, i blow up their mosque.

This is the best a putative deity could come up with? Do back to them just as they did to you? No appeal to a more objective legal system or standardized punishments?